DISQUS

VentureBeat: Job site NotchUp thinks companies should pay applicants for interviews

  • Squasher98 · 1 year ago
    I see this as a flawed model.

    Who wouldn't be willing to do an interview for $300?
  • Matt Marshall · 1 year ago
    Yeah, I'd interview for $200.

    Anthony, re notchup's dismissal of my phd as having any value, that actually might be reasonable. My phd is in political science, and for most jobs, that spells danger. i'm way overqualified or wrongly fitted for most jobs.
  • Stiennon · 1 year ago
    I joined NotchUp Friday. The calculator said I should charge over $1,100 for an interview. I could do that all day! :-)

    This is the stickiest concept I have *ever* seen. And certainly the best inducement for allowing an application to scrape my LinkedIn profile and connections. They promise to share 10% of each connection's earnings! Whoohoo, I hope they get lots of employers signed up because I have lots of employable connections!

    If you want an invite to the beta just email me at stiennongmail.com ;-)
  • Martin Edic · 1 year ago
    I think their viral strategy is pretty strong- I got three invites this week before hearing anything about them. The LinkedIn scrape worked well and they offer you the ability to select which of your LinkedIn contacts you want to send invites to.
    Will employers pay? That's the $64,000 question. I don't know how they are promoting that unless its a build it fast database plan, then pitch it to employers.
  • Tom Alsberg · 1 year ago
    I just got a few invitations to NotchUp, so I signed up. Never heard of it before, but thought hey - what's there to lose?

    Then I got to this "name a price" thing which appeared quite silly, so I looked up any mention of this site, and I still can't quite understand the point.

    Why should anybody offer me money to invite me to an interview through NotchUp, if they can do it outside NotchUp for free?

    Let's say somebody finds my profile on NotchUp, and decides they might like to employ me. If I'd be interested anyway, then it's a waste of money, as they could save those $75 (that's the minimum price NotchUp let you state) by contacting me. If I talk to them just because they offer to pay me for it, and it's even more a waste of money, and time...

    Or do NotchUp expect that one who signs up will then make himself unavailable unless approached through that site?

    I must be missing something here. Or maybe not... Enlighten me.
  • Jack · 1 year ago
    Totally ludicrous. There would be much more mileage in a model when the applicant pays $5 to upload a CV so that employers don't have to sift through potential applicants who uploaded a CV on a whim after a bad day at work.
  • Russ · 1 year ago
    A colleague forwarded me this article, and what I find interesting is that no one apparently has noticed their Terms of Service and how they may effectively sell your name in the form of a list.

    All of your information may be secure, but what about your personal privacy? Are we so lured by the ease of use in uploading a LinkedIn profile and the notion that someone should PAY us to interview that we're willing to gloss over the details of our personal information?

    Clearly, the big story seems to be overlooked.

    Granted, I didn't make it to the privacy settings on the registration form because I had to agree to their Terms of Service, which I could not do. Maybe there's more than meets the eye here, but when compared to other sites, such as LinkedIn, I certainly did not feel the same sense of security.
  • Jennifer · 1 year ago
    The Terms of Use on the site made me very uncomfortable as an individual an employer might seek.
  • Brad K. · 1 year ago
    Why would people who are in demand and making a good amount of money want to spend a day interviewing for a few hundred dollars? Especially if they aren’t actually interested in moving. For anyone that’s truly a good candidate, they would rather get paid to get HIRED.

    That’s where PROSUMES.COM comes in. Better business model, in my humble opinion.

    Granted, I helped launch the company but it just makes more sense.
  • Marc · 1 year ago
    The premise of this business model is that offering money will motivate otherwise happy employees to take time to interview for a new role. It does not address the client side of the value proposition. How does this service increase the probability a candidate will be qualified for a role. It doesn't. Only pre-screening interviews with HR or a recruiter can do that.
  • Jason · 1 year ago
    Brad K., do you have some kind of Google Alert for NotchUp posts? I've read a half-dozen blog posts about NotchUp where you've attached your own "humble opinion" about this company you "helped launch." Please stop.
  • Mitchel · 1 year ago
    I'm having a hard time hiring for a position right now and would never consider using this. You interview because you want to work for us, not for a spiff. This seems like a total waste of time and money for employers (you know, those guys paying the bills).
  • Jacob Freis · 1 year ago
    Hold on a second, I thought you had to be hired before you get paid! In anycase they didn't pay for a website design. I can't believe they stole the design straight off of Grandcentral.com
  • alinkedinuser · 1 year ago
    I sent the following to Notchup's tech support:
    ===================================
    I'm a registered member and I've been trying more then a few times to import my profile (and contacts) from linkedin.
    It always fail, and I receive the following error:

    * We could not sign in to Linkedin with the below email and password
    * Please check both fields and try again

    I know that the login details are correct because I'm using them to enter Linkedin successfully.
    Is there a problem with the import feature?
    Can you please assist?
    Thanks
    ==============================
    The auto-reply I got from notchup
    ==============================
    We appreciate your support of our beta program. If your message is
    about the LinkedIn import profile/contacts features not working,
    please know that we are working on it and plan to release a new
    version soon. Thank you for your patience.

    If your message is about a different subject, we will respond to you
    as soon as possible.

    Regards,
    NotchUp Customer Support

    ===============================
    Thinking out loud: why did notchup waste my time
    letting me try over and over again to import my Linkedin
    details, knowing it does not work? A simple note on their
    web site will do. This dishonesty right at the beginning is
    not a good sign. They of all should know that people's
    time is valuable.
  • DavidE · 1 year ago
    I tried 10 times to import my data from LinkedIn. The button seems to be gone now.

    I agree - not letting people know in the first place is a bad idea, especially considering that this is one of their most highly-touted features. Of course, that's not all that unusual these days, sadly.
  • Bryan Starbuck · 1 year ago
    TalentSpring (my company), JobFox, and ItzBig are three companies working on making hiring more efficient. Now NotchUp is also doing some interesting things in this space.

    The first three are working on advanced ways to job seekers to their ideal job opening. And employers to their ideal job candidate.

    TalentSpring goes beyond that to rank resumes within an industry. We do this to benefit Job Seekers by getting the attention of employees. Job seekers rank well in areas they are passionate about and where they have invested in their work experience and education.

    Since job seekers will rank well in areas they are interested in, we can bring large numbers of employers back to that job seeker. Specifically, we email a wide range of employers of job types that the job seeker considers ideal. This way the job seeker wins because they have their ideal types of employers actively listening to them. (Ranking resumes gives us the power to accomplish this)

    Bryan Starbuck
    CEO
    www.TalentSpring.com
  • Brendan · 1 year ago
    I have been looking to switch positions. I have a resume on all the websites and all I get is constant spam from recruiters even though I have checked direct employers only. Time will tell if NotchUp is any better or if it will be more of the same. Just like an employer wants to interview serious candidates, I like the model of employers paying a potential candidate to interview. It means they are serious about hiring and not just interviewing people and wasting your time. It is easy to show up with your "A" game when you are getting paid to interview.
  • Rani · 1 year ago
    My company, Leapways.com (http://www.leapways.com), is also focusing on Job and career market. The main difference we have from others is that it is 100% free of charge for both employers and job seekers.

    We will be soon launching an Interview Service which is aimed at the hiring managers across corporate America. The idea is to take some pressure out of the hiring manager (who's real job is not hiring). We will take the ownership of the filtering the candidates. In other words, our representatives will take the interview and certify a candidate.

    Also, a candidate can take an interview in a technology area and get certified in advance. Those candidates will be listed as "Certified" in their profile.

    Our interviews are real world technical architects, working in IT field for fore than 10 years. That makes a huge difference. "We will help you hire the RIGHT candidate" - That is our motto.

    Regards,
    Rani
    Vice President
    LeapConcepts
  • Yuvraj · 1 year ago
    I think Notchup is trying to solve a bog problem in recruiting industry and thats about reaching out to passive job seekers "faster" usually employers waste significant amount of precisous time in reaching out to right candidates by trying to use job boards and otehr obvious sources of hiring. When they fail to get right profiles they go to professional hiring researcher and head hunters. Now headhunters will definately charge you significantly more (aroun 10-25%) of annual base package. If Notchup can get you some passive job seekers who fit in your position and can help you save significant time and money it makes a big sense. But.....how will they ensure that the recruiter who is using their wesite does not head hunt the candidate directly
  • Carter · 1 year ago
    Well, competition is inevitable. Although, since these guys are launching so soon after NotchUp’s big splash, I would guess they’ve been brewing this up for awhile now.
  • Web development lucknow · 2 months ago
    The first three are working on advanced ways to job seekers to their ideal job opening. And employers to their ideal job candidate.
    This is good article.
    thank you
  • abercrombie622 · 1 month ago
    Why tiffany jewellery is your best choice?Compared with other jewellerys,tiffany jewellery have many advantages.
    www.tiffanyjewelleryonsale.co.uk