DISQUS

VentureBeat: Oorja Protonics, alcohol-based fuel cell company, gets $15M

  • Savanh Prasasouk · 2 years ago
    Since Oorja is such a new company, what are Oorja's competitors in the US?
  • Daniel Sweeney · 2 years ago
    We don't know what kind of alcohol they're using so that makes it hard to determine exact competitors. Several companies are developing direct methanol fuel cells including MTI, Smart Fuel Cells, Manhattan Scientific, and most of the Japanese consumer electronics firm. Medis Technologies has an ethanol fuel cell
  • Dennis Morrow · 2 years ago
    In September 2006, I visited Crown Battery, who has an exclusive agreement with Oorja. I brought customer representatives from GM and the US Army to observe the demonstration of an Oorja 1 kW methanol fuel cell. Oorja President, Sanjeev made the initial presentation. The demonstration developed only 300 W. Sanjeev offered assurance that a properly working demonstration unit would be available in 2 months, however, we have not yet received it.

    Dennis Morrow
    Director of Engineering
    EAGLE TUGS
  • Frank Cardaropoli · 2 years ago
    Have you seen the new unit and if so have you had the opportunity to test?
  • Frank Cardaropoli · 2 years ago
    My understanding that none of the above mentioned companies have a on-board system similar to this unit. Am I incorrect?
  • Frank Cardaropoli · 2 years ago
    It is my understanding that none of the above mentioned companies have a on-board system. Am I incorrect?
  • Jim Horwitz · 2 years ago
    Secretive Oorja seems to have signed an agreement with a forklift company yesterday. The other MHV fuel cell players are Ballard (through Plug Power's Cellex & General Hydrogen), fellow canuck Hydrogenics, Nuvera, and German Proton Power. All are pure hydrogen fueled which makes them cost-effective, particularly with over 100 or so vehicles justifying the H2 fueling station cost. German SFC Smart is the only 'commercial' methanol FC, but their mobility apps are limited to RVs. The small Medis charger is disposable, therefore is not a fuel cell. Getting a higher power (500W+) FC to run on hydrated methanol is not easy, and therefore much more costly than hydrogen fueled systems. So, does it float? Only the VCs can guess for sure.
  • 7 card stud poker gratis cazin · 1 year ago
    Wonderful web site, was very useful. Lovely touch having this guestbook. Thanks
  • gambling directory · 1 year ago
    This is one super duper site
  • Jim · 1 year ago
    Startup, like Oorja, always played game like that.
  • Jim · 1 year ago
    Exactly! Those major fuel cell players have proved that it is not easier to get a higher power (500W+) FC to run on methanol. If Oorja does not have a strong IP to ensure people it can do the job, yes, only the VCs can GUESS!
  • Dennis Morrow · 1 year ago
    I visited Oorja Protronics at the NA08 Material Handling Show in Cleveland on April 22. The Oorja Pak product on
    display was the culmination of the development which I viewed originally in 2006. I also viewed the Orja Pak installed on and operating in an FMC AGV at the show. This positive experience has encouraged me to proceed with Oorja.

    Dennis Morrow
    Director of Engineering
    Eagle Tugs